Utah is growing fast, and most of our cities are feeling it. Downtowns are redeveloping, aging strip malls are being reimagined, and new neighborhoods are going in near transit lines and town centers. The question we hear from city staff and elected officials more than any other is some version of this: how do we get the development we actually want?
For a growing number of Utah communities, the answer is form-based code.
What Is Form-Based Code?
Traditional zoning is built around use. It separates residential from commercial from industrial and regulates development mostly through density limits, setbacks, and lists of permitted uses. That approach has shaped most American cities for the last century, and it’s a big reason so many commercial corridors look the same: a building set far back from the street behind a large parking lot.
Form-based code flips the priority. Instead of starting with what happens inside a building, it starts with what the building looks like and how it relates to the street around it. A form-based code regulates things like:
- Where a building sits on its lot, often through build-to lines rather than minimum setbacks
- Building height, massing, and frontage types
- Window and entrance requirements along the street
- Parking location, usually behind or beside buildings instead of in front
- The design of streets, sidewalks, and public spaces
Uses still matter, but they’re treated more flexibly. The thinking is that a well-designed building can host a coffee shop today, an office tomorrow, and apartments down the road, and the street will still work.
Form-based codes also read differently. They rely heavily on diagrams, illustrations, and tables, which makes them far easier for property owners, architects, and residents to understand than pages of dense zoning text.
Why Utah Cities Are Making the Shift
Form-based code isn’t new to Utah, and it isn’t new to us. Civil Solutions Group has worked on many form-based code projects across Utah, Salt Lake, Wasatch, and Cache counties.
In North Logan, we led the development of a form-based code for the city’s future city center, guiding the process from public workshops and task force meetings through drafting and finalizing the code with the city. We also provided form-based code writing and zoning development as part of North Ogden’s Downtown Master Plan. And on the development side, we designed Brookside Meadows in Logan, a mixed-residential neighborhood built to meet Logan City’s form-based code, which gave us a firsthand look at how these codes play out for builders and property owners.
From our work with communities, a few reasons for the shift keep coming up.
Predictability. With a conventional code, a community often doesn’t know what a project will look like until it shows up in front of the planning commission. A form-based code sets those expectations upfront. Developers know what’s expected, residents know what’s coming, and staff can spend less time negotiating design on a project-by-project basis.
Better places. Walkable town centers and lively main streets don’t happen by accident. Form-based code puts the focus on the experience at street level, which is where people actually live their daily lives.
Smarter growth. As Utah cities plan for more housing and more transit-oriented development, form-based code offers a way to add density in targeted areas while protecting the character of surrounding neighborhoods. Many cities apply it only to specific districts, like a downtown or a corridor, and leave single-family neighborhoods untouched.
A faster approval path. When the rules are clear and the community has already agreed on the vision, projects that meet the code can often move through review more efficiently.
What It Takes to Get It Right
Form-based code is a powerful tool, but it isn’t a template you can pull off the shelf. The codes that work best are rooted in real community input and a clear understanding of local conditions.
A successful process usually includes:
- A clear vision. Most form-based codes grow out of a general plan, master plan, or small area plan. If the community hasn’t agreed on what it wants a place to become, the code has nothing to implement.
- Meaningful public engagement. Workshops, design charrettes, and visual preference exercises help residents and property owners see what different outcomes could look like before anything is written into code. In North Logan, workshops with residents, a task force, the City Council, and the Planning Commission shaped the code long before it was finalized.
- An honest look at the market. A code that requires four-story mixed-use buildings in a market that can only support two stories will sit unused. The standards need to match what’s realistic.
- Thoughtful transitions. Some of the hardest conversations in any form-based code process happen at the edges, where a new district meets an established neighborhood. Building height and stepbacks along those edges deserve careful attention.
- Integration with the rest of the code. A form-based code has to work alongside existing subdivision rules, engineering standards, and approval procedures. Gaps between them create confusion for applicants and staff alike.
Where Civil Solutions Group Fits In
Because our team includes planners, landscape architects, civil engineers, and surveyors, we see community planning from more than one angle. A street section on paper needs to work with real utilities, drainage, and right-of-way. A building frontage requirement needs to make sense on lots with actual grades and dimensions. Bringing those disciplines together early helps cities write codes that are both inspiring and buildable.
That’s also why we look beyond the buildings themselves. Our North Logan code was developed with long-term sustainability in mind, encouraging durable buildings, mixed use, alternative transportation, low-impact stormwater design, and water-wise landscaping.
Is Form-Based Code Right for Your Community?
Not every city needs to replace its entire zoning ordinance. For many communities, the best starting point is a single area with a clear opportunity, like a downtown, a key corridor, or land around a future transit stop. Starting small lets the city test the approach, learn from it, and expand when the time is right.
If your community is wrestling with how to guide growth, revitalize a main street, or get more out of a redevelopment area, form-based code is worth a serious look. We’d be glad to talk through whether it’s a good fit and what the process could look like for your city.
